Yohimbine
vs Muira puama * in
the treatment of erectile dysfunction
The
term impotence has traditionally been used to signify
the inability of the male to attain and maintain erection of
the penis sufficient to permit satisfactory sexual
intercourse. Impotence, in most circumstances, is more
precisely referred to as erectile dysfunction as this term
differentiates itself from loss of libido, premature
ejaculation, or inability to achieve orgasm. 1
An
estimated 10 to 20 million men suffer from erectile
dysfunction. This number is expected to increase dramatically
as the median age of the population increases. Currently,
erectile dysfunction is thought to affect over 25% of men over
the age of 50. 1,2
Although
the frequency of erectile dysfunction increases with age, it
must be stressed that aging itself is not a cause of
impotence. Although the amount and force of the ejaculate as
well as the need to ejaculate decrease with age, the capacity
for erection is retained. Men are capable of retaining their
sexual virility well into their 80s.
Erectile
dysfunction may be due to organic or psychogenic factors. In
the overwhelming majority of cases the cause is organic, i.e.,
it is due to some physiological reason. In fact, in men over
the age of 50, organic causes are responsible for erectile
dysfunction in over 90%. 3 In the past, a man with impotence
who was able to have nighttime or early morning erections was
thought to have psychogenic impotence. However, it is now
recognized that this is not a reliable indicator. 2
Yohimbine
The
only FDA approved medicine for impotence is yohimbine - an
alkaloid isolated from the bark of the yohimbe tree (pausinystalia
johimbe) native to tropical West Africa. Yohimbine
hydrochloride increases libido, but its primary action is to
increase blood flow to erectile tissue. Yohimbine is a
selective alpha-2 receptor antagonist. Contrary to a popular
misconception, yohimbine has no effects on testosterone
levels.
When
used alone, yohimbine is successful in 34% to 43% of cases.
4,5 It is effective in both psychogenic and organic causes of
impotence. The standard dose of yohimbine is 15 to 20 mg per
day, however, higher doses, up to 42mg of yohimbine, may prove
to be more effective.
To
illustrate the benefits to be expected in clinical practice,
lets examine the results from one of the more recent
double-blind studies. In the study, 82 men with erectile
dysfunction selected from a Veterans Administration population
with a high incidence of diabetes and vascular disease
underwent a multifactorial evaluation, including determination
of penile brachial blood pressure index, cavernosography,
sacral evoked response, testosterone and prolactin
determination, sexual dysfunction inventory and arousal test.
After
one month of treatment with a maximum of 42.0 mg oral
yohimbine hydrochloride daily 14% of the patients experienced
restoration of full and sustained erections, 20% reported a
partial response to the therapy and 65% reported no
improvement. In comparison, only three patients reported a
positive effect in the placebo group. Maximum effect with
yohimbine takes two to three weeks to manifest itself.
Yohimbine was active in some patients with arterial
insufficiency and a unilateral sacral reflex arc lesion, and
in one with low serum testosterone levels. The 34% response is
somewhat encouraging given the study population.
Side
effects often make yohimbine very difficult to utilize.
Yohimbine can induce anxiety, panic attacks, and
hallucinations in some individuals. Other side effects include
elevations in blood pressure and heart rate, dizziness,
headache, and skin flushing. Yohimbine should not be used in
individuals with kidney disease, women, and individuals with
psychological disturbances
Although
crude yohimbe bark preparations are available commercially,
use of pure yohimbine hydrochloride is preferred. There are no
commercial sources of yohimbe bark that are available to
physicians or in health food stores which actually state the
level of yohimbine per dosage. Without knowing the content of
yohimbine, it is virtually impossible to prescribe an
effective and consistent dosage. Because of the yohimbine
content of yohimbe bark, the FDA classifies yohimbe as an
unsage herb.
Muira
puama
Preliminary
research indicates one of the best herbs to use for erectile
dysfunction or lack of libido may be Muira puama (also known
as potency wood). This shrub is native to Brazil and has long
been used as a powerful aphrodisiac and nerve stimulant in
South American folk medicine. 6 A recent study has validated
its safety and effectiveness in improving libido and sexual
function in some patients.
At
the Institute of Sexology in Paris, France, under the
supervision of one of the worlds foremost authorities on
secual function, Dr. Jacques Waynberg, a clinical study with
262 patients complaining of lack of secual desire and the
inability to attain or maintain an erection demonstrated Muira
puama extract to be effective in many cases. 7 Within two
weeks, at a daily dose of 1 to 1.5 grams of the extract (4:1),
62% of patients with loss of libido claimed that the treatment
had dynamic effect while 51% of patients with erection
failures felt that Muira puama was of benefit. These
results are extremely promising and seem to indicate that
Muira puama may provide better results that yohimbine without
side effects.
Presently,
the mechanism of action of Muira puama is unknown. From the
preliminary information, it appears that it works on enhancing
both psychological and physical aspects of sexual function.
Future research will undoubtedly shed additional light on this
extremely promising herb for erectile dysfunction.
References:
1.
NIII Consensus Conference Panel on Impotence: Impotence,
JAAAMA 270:83-90, 1993
2.
Lener SE.Melnum A and Chost GJ: a review of erectile
dysfunction: New insights and more questions. Journal of
Urology 149:1216-55, 1993
3.
Morley JF. Management of impotence. Postgraduate
Medicine 93:65-72, 1991.
4.
Susset JG, et al: Effect of yohimbine hydrochloride on
erectile impotence: A double-blindstudy. J. Urology
141:1360-3, 1989.
5.
Moreales A, et al: Is yohimbine effective in the
treatment of organic impotence? Results of a controlled trial.
J.Urology 137:1168-72, 1987.
6.
Duke JA: Handbook of Medicinal Herbs. CRC Press, Boca
Raton, FL 1985.
7.
Waynberg J: Aphrodisiacs: Contributions to the clinical
validation of the traditional use of Psychopetalum guyanna.
Presented at The First International Congress on
Ethnopharmacology, Strasbourg, France June 5-9, 1990 (Susset
JG et al. Effect of Yohimbine hydrochloride on erectile
impotence, a double-blind study. J. Urol 141(6):1360-3, 1989. 6
CAUSES
OF IMPOTENCE
Organic
(85%)
Vascular insufficiency
Atherosclerosis
Pelvic surgery
Pelvic trauma
Venous shunting
Drugs
Antihistamines
Antihypertensives
Anticholinergics
Antidepressants
Antipsychotics
Tranquilizers
Others
Alcohol and tobacco
Endocrine disorders
Diabetes
Hypothyroidism
Decreased male sex
hormones
Elevated prolactin levels
High serum estrogen levels
Diseases or trauma to male
sexual organs
Diseases of the penis
Prostate disorders
Neurological diseases
Pelvic trauma
Pelvic surgery
Multiple sclerosis
Psychologic
(10%)
Psychiatric Illness
Stress
Performance anxiety
Depression
Unknown
(5%)
Return to Science & Research |